0
Skip to Content
little loaf bakeshop
Order Ahead
Pastry Pre-Orders
Kitchen Pre-Orders (weekdays only)
About
About
Blog
Contact
Catering
Where To Find Us
In Store Food Menu
Ingredients
Events
Gift Cards
little loaf bakeshop
Order Ahead
Pastry Pre-Orders
Kitchen Pre-Orders (weekdays only)
About
About
Blog
Contact
Catering
Where To Find Us
In Store Food Menu
Ingredients
Events
Gift Cards
Folder: Order Ahead
Back
Pastry Pre-Orders
Kitchen Pre-Orders (weekdays only)
Folder: About
Back
About
Blog
Contact
Catering
Where To Find Us
In Store Food Menu
Ingredients
Events
Gift Cards
Pastry Pre-Orders Peanut Butter and Jelly Thumbprint Cookie (Gluten Free)
2037867b-677c-477a-ac9f-a5ed686fc135.jpg Image 1 of
2037867b-677c-477a-ac9f-a5ed686fc135.jpg
2037867b-677c-477a-ac9f-a5ed686fc135.jpg

Peanut Butter and Jelly Thumbprint Cookie (Gluten Free)

$4.50

Chewy, creamy, and nostalgic, this cookie is for all of you who used to. (or still do!) peel off the crust and just eat the middle!

Quantity:
Add To Cart

Chewy, creamy, and nostalgic, this cookie is for all of you who used to. (or still do!) peel off the crust and just eat the middle!

Chewy, creamy, and nostalgic, this cookie is for all of you who used to. (or still do!) peel off the crust and just eat the middle!

You Might Also Like

Double Chocolate Chip Tahini Cookie vegan double chocolate chip tahini cookie
Double Chocolate Chip Tahini Cookie
$4.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie with Maldon Sea Salt vegan chocolate chip cookie with sea salt
Chocolate Chip Cookie with Maldon Sea Salt
$4.50
Funfetti Cookie vegan funfetti cookie
Funfetti Cookie
$4.50

© Little Loaf Bakeshop 2025, All rights reserved.

New Paltz, NY, USA